Why “Staying Together for the Kids” Might Do More Harm Than Good

Is it really better to stay married for the kids? Explore why divorce done well can be healthier than a bad marriage—and how to prioritize your child’s emotional well-being during family transitions.

Like most things in life, marriage and divorce are far more nuanced than many social narratives allow. While conventional wisdom tells us to "stay together for the kids," real-life evidence and emotional health insights suggest otherwise. 

Here’s the truth we need to talk about: 

There are good ways to do divorce—and bad ways to do marriage. 

The Myth of “Staying Together for the Kids” 

Many parents choose to remain in unhappy relationships because they believe it's better for their children. But in reality, this choice can lead to homes filled with emotional distance or even chronic conflict. And both of those scenarios can have long-lasting negative effects on children. 

Here’s why this matters: 

Children thrive in environments where they feel safe, supported, and emotionally connected to their caregivers. When the home becomes a place of tension or emotional withdrawal, it undermines the secure attachment children need to develop healthy coping mechanisms and relationships later in life. 

What Does “Secure Attachment” Really Mean? 

Secure attachment is more than just love—it's a nervous system-level sense of safety with caregivers. It's the emotional foundation that allows children to: 

● Turn to parents for comfort and safety 

● Feel confident in expressing themselves 

● Build resilience in the face of challenges

But in high-conflict or emotionally distant homes, parents are often too dysregulated or detached themselves to provide that secure base. Over time, this can create emotional instability in children, leading to difficulties in relationships, self-esteem, and emotional regulation. 

The Patterns We Inherit (and Pass On) 

Children tend to internalize what they grow up with as “normal.” Without intentional intervention, these early experiences become the blueprint for their future friendships, partnerships, and sense of self-worth. 

Ask yourself this powerful question: 

“Would I be okay with my son or daughter being in a relationship like mine?” 

If your answer is no, it might be time to take a hard look at your current dynamic—and consider whether change is necessary, even if it feels uncomfortable. 

Divorce Isn’t the Enemy—How You Divorce Matters 

If a couple decides that separating is healthier than staying together, it’s the how that makes the biggest difference for the children involved. 

A well-handled divorce can actually be far less harmful than a dysfunctional marriage. Here are essential strategies to co-parent in a child-centered way

Do’s of Healthy Co-Parenting After Divorce: 

Allow your child to process their emotions. Let them express sadness, anger, or confusion without judgment. 

Be a safe space. Allow for the child to talk about the other parent without allowing your feelings to come into the conversation. 

Normalize hard conversations. Kids are often more aware than we think. Create an open-door policy for honest, age-appropriate discussions. 

Don’ts of Harmful Co-Parenting: 

Don’t put kids in the middle. Avoid making them choose sides or carry logistical/emotional burdens. 

Don’t speak negatively about the other parent. This creates confusion and can fracture their emotional foundation.

Don’t use your child as your therapist. It’s not their job to manage your emotional experience. You need to get that support from other adults in your life. 


Final Thoughts: Choose Presence Over Pretense 

Maintaining the appearance of a family at the expense of genuine connection and emotional health doesn't serve your children in the long run. What they need most is attuned, emotionally regulated caregivers who can support them—whether that’s within one home or two. 

Choosing a path that prioritizes the well-being of everyone involved—especially the kids—may look different than what society expects, but it can lead to healthier outcomes for the whole family.

 

Resources

Visit our website for more info!

More on COuPLES

Next
Next

The Top Reasons for Divorce (and What We Can Learn From Them)